TRAI’s Affordable Voice-Only Plan Proposal Faces Strong Opposition from Telcos
Telecom operators have strongly opposed a new proposal from the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India (TRAI). The regulator aims to make cheaper standalone voice and SMS plans more widely available.
According to a recent Economic Times report, Jio, Airtel, and Vodafone Idea raised their objections during a TRAI open-house consultation on June 15. The meeting focused on the Draft Telecom Consumer Protection Thirteenth Amendment Regulation, 2026.
Under the proposal, operators must offer voice-and-SMS-only packs. These packs would cover all validity periods that currently exist for bundled plans. Moreover, the standalone options would carry lower prices than data-inclusive bundles. TRAI also wants these plans to appear more prominently on customer interfaces.
However, the telecom companies urged TRAI not to interfere in tariff design. They argued that plan structures and pricing should stay market-driven. Additionally, they warned that extra regulatory rules could harm their business models and reduce investment returns.
Reliance Jio questioned the technical feasibility of the idea. The operator explained that modern 4G and 5G networks use a common Internet Protocol architecture. As a result, voice services run on the same framework as data. Jio also highlighted risks of misuse. For instance, shorter-validity voice packs could enable spam and fraudulent activities. Furthermore, the company noted that 88 percent of its entry-level users already consume mobile data. Therefore, demand for pure voice plans remains low.
Vodafone Idea raised similar concerns. The operator pointed out that smartphones generate small amounts of data traffic automatically. Background processes, software updates, and authentication services often use data. Without any data allowance, users might face extra charges.
Bharti Airtel emphasized the growing importance of internet access. The company stated that digital services now depend heavily on connectivity. Consequently, wider promotion of voice-only plans could slow down India’s digital inclusion efforts.
On the other side, consumer groups supported the proposal. The Consumer Protection Association in Himmatnagar, Gujarat, estimated that India has 300 to 350 million feature phone users. Out of these, 100 to 150 million subscribers do not use mobile data at all.
These advocates argued that many users pay for benefits they never consume. They estimated that this segment wastes between Rs. 15,000 crore and Rs. 20,000 crore every year on unused data. In addition, they highlighted poor network conditions in tribal, remote, and hilly areas. Internet access remains unreliable in those regions despite data-inclusive plans.
Consumer groups also noted that entry-level recharge packs often result in higher effective data costs. Users pay around Rs. 94 to Rs. 99 per GB. This rate exceeds what premium plan customers pay.
TRAI will now review all submissions from operators, consumer organisations, and other stakeholders. The regulator will then decide whether to implement the proposed amendment.